Among the many other oddities in our financial world that are now accepted as “normal”, future historians will be left to pass judgment on how, here in 2010, U.S. monetary policy continues to punish the group that the nation needs most if it is to somehow restore balance to its money flows – savers. This New York Times story takes up the issue:
Perversely, coming after a devastating financial crisis caused by companies and households that feasted on borrowing, ultralow interest rates are penalizing people who have paid down their debt and are now trying to save. It is also punishing those who rely on the proceeds of their nest eggs to pay the bills.
“It’s the whole point of low rates, to entice borrowing and discourage saving, but it means a massive wealth transfer from savers to borrowers,” said Greg McBride, a senior financial analyst at Bankrate.com. “It is a trend on steroids now because interest rates have been cut to the bone.”
For example, anyone keeping $500,000 in a 12-month certificate of deposit earning a rate of 1.5 percent annually — one of the best savings rates available nationally these days — would earn $7,500 a year, hardly enough to live on. Just three years ago, that same investment would have generated $26,250.
…
“You have spent your life being prudent, building a nest egg for your retirement, and now the returns are terrible,” said Todd E. Petzel, chief investment adviser at Offit Capital Advisors, a wealth advisory company in New York. “I am 58 years old. I know lots of my peers who are thinking of retiring, and they are scared to death.”
I really feel for a lot of these fifty-somethings and their elders who are just now learning how central bankers have stacked the deck against them and are, unjustifiably, as scared of owning gold as they are of outlasting their meager savings, now earning one percent.











![[Most Recent USD from www.kitco.com]](http://www.weblinks247.com/indexes/idx24_usd_en_2.gif)

Paying back debt is saving money. Paying back debt at a low interest rate hence helps savers.
Savings rate is going higher, not lower. Why? Because people are paying their debts.
Low interest rates are normal, high interest rates are abnormal.
The reason why gold went up 30% this year is because it is risky. Older people do not need to risk their life savings on commodities for a comfortable retirement. What they need is social security. The rest is just gravy.
We must be thinking of something different when we see the word “savings”. I don’t think anything you just wrote is correct…
The reason gold went up 30% is because paper went down 30%. Paper is not money. Gold is money.
Paper is not money but rather currency. Gold is not money but rather a commodity.
The vast majority of transactions done in modern time is through currency. It is much more efficient than barter.
If you think that currency is just paper and worthless. I’ll trade pound for pound that currency for a office supply paper.
Why are you here?
Paying back debt is saving money. One has to pay back debt before becoming a net saver.
Savings = Income – Spending.
Paying back debt is not spending – you already spent when bought that item. Hence it is savings.
Getting into more debt however is spending. Paying it back is saving.
How is that not correct?
It’s hardly worth arguing over semantics – far be it from me to stop you from thinking that paying down debt is not some form of saving or savings as both paying down debt and spending less than you make are both things that should be encouraged, not punished.
What you are asking for is low inflation and high interest rates?
I think that is impossible. Unless you want to destroy the economy.
There are no free lunches in economics.
Low inflation and high interest rates are impossible? What world are you living in?
Paying down debt is not savings. It is just paying down debt. It says a lot about this world and how accustomed people are to being in debt that this waffle is trotted out.
Debt, ie a loan/credit card, is satisfying CURRENT demand/need by sacrificing FUTURE spending.
Savings, ie a deposit of money, is satisfying FUTURE demand/need by sacrificing CURRENT spending.
Besides health care – well even that I figured a way to lower my costs, inflation is non existent in my life.
Why the conundrum all the time for a household? Should I pay back my debt or save? They are the same thing. What matters is the interest rate and what the debt or savings are used for.
Or how about this? Should I use my savings or should I get a loan?
How about merely having ositive real interest rates, professor?
Again, Why is he here? He’s obviously used to just living in constant debt and to his type, they think they’re saving. They LIKE low interest rates because they are debtors. He totally missed the point that SAVERS who are not debtors are punished by these rates. But to his type, being deep in debt is just a way of life. Add to it a complete lack of understanding of gold and you can see why we have this problem. The broke-arse hands-out types outnumber the rest of us.
Wrong – I have been following this mess for years. I am a net saver. But I also am a worker stiff. Not even close to a retiree like the Boomer farts, about 20 or 25 years away actually.
I also don’t believe that gold is money but rather a commodity. It is closer to a bubble than Treasury Bonds. Once the economy ever goes back to normal, aka not debt based growth, gold will be cheap again.
They are indeed punishing savers. However, don’t cry for 58 y/o’s.
They may be getting poor returns on savings now, but these are the same people who were, in their prime savings years (80’s and 90’s) benefitting hugely from “easy” runups in the stock market, where simply choosing a stock mutual fund and holding it would return huge returns, year after year.
Save your pity for the younger savers, who were too young for the good years, and only became able to save 10 years ago, when things went sour, and now have a bleak future ahead.
If you can’t beat em, join em. Borrow as much as you can on a mortgage at 4.5% and use your cash to buy gold and oil and you will probably do quite well.
Thanks for feeling pity for me.
[...] and gives future seniors a double-whammy even if they do everything “right.” Further, the low interest rates encourage people (and the government) to borrow money they might have a hard …. While this might boost the economy in the short run, in the long run it’s just a longer bit [...]
Low inflation and high interest rates are possible if the real economic growth is high (I do not expect to see it in the forseeble future).
However, even in the current environment the rates could be 1-2 points higher.
Only way that happens is if fiscal stimulus is given another go. Ain’t gonna happen in our political climate.
I am getting 6.1% on my 150 day CD in Australia and the currency is going up against the US dollar. My poor old American dollars are not even getting 1%. Can we please have another crash sir, so I can move my cash sir.